Home / Europe / Human Security Centre responds to Defence Sub-committee report on UK defence in the Arctic

Human Security Centre responds to Defence Sub-committee report on UK defence in the Arctic

15 August, 2018

The House of Commons Defence Sub-committee has published ‘On Thin Ice: UK Defence in the Arctic’, which outlines the conclusions of its inquiry into defence in the Arctic. The report illustrates the nature of the challenges the UK faces in the region, and examines the resources required to meet them.

In its evidence to the inquiry, the Human Security Centre (HSC) raised concerns regarding challenges in and emanating from the Arctic, most notably to NATO’s traditional ‘Northern Flank’ – an area centred upon Norway and adjacent waters. While the Arctic has in recent decades been an area of low tension, its role as a key base for Russian military forces has recently returned to the fore. The HSC is particularly pleased to note the report’s following points:

  • The prospect of Russian military power being projected from the Arctic into the North Atlantic has returned and a comprehensive strategy is required to meet this challenge.
  • It is not clear that sufficient platforms – particularly in the field of anti-submarine warfare – are available to the UK to counter the threats emanating from the Arctic region.
  • The contribution of the Royal Marines and the Royal Navy’s landing vessels to the UK’s cold weather capability must be factored in to the ongoing assessment of Britain’s future amphibious forces.
  • The UK Government must ensure that adequate resources are available to support Arctic and cold weather training exercises.

Dr Rowan Allport, Senior Fellow and Security and Defence team lead at the HSC, said:

“Even with the resurgence of the Russian threat, the importance of the Arctic and the surrounding region to the defence of both the NATO states in general and the UK specifically has remained under-appreciated. It is now vital that, as was the case in the Cold War, the region is recognised as a vital theatre of both deterrence and forward defence.

The forthcoming Exercise Trident Juncture 2018, which will take place in Norway in October and November this year and will feature some 40,000 personnel, will help remedy decades of neglect of NATO’s northern flank. In the longer term, the UK has the potential to offer a range of platforms – including the new Queen Elizabeth-class aircraft carriers and P-8A Poseidon maritime patrol aircraft – that could provide key capabilities to the Alliance in the region.”


Image: Royal Marines training in Norway (MoD/Crown Copyright)

About Rowan Allport

Dr Rowan Allport is a Deputy Director who leads the HSC's Security and Defence team. Rowan holds a PhD in Politics and a MA in Conflict, Governance and Development from the University of York, as well as a BA (Hons) in Politics, Philosophy and Economics from the University of Hull. Specialising in strategic analysis and international security, Rowan's primary areas of interest lie in the defence issues in and around the NATO region, interstate conflict and US foreign policy discourse. He is also the lead author of HSC's recent ‘Fire and Ice: A New Maritime Strategy for NATO’s Northern Flank’ report. Rowan's publication credits include articles and commentary in Foreign Policy, The Diplomat, The Hill, DefenseOne, RealClearDefense, The Strategist, UK Defence Journal, Politics.co.uk and The National Interest. He has previously worked as a lobbyist for the Whitehouse Consultancy in Westminster, and as a Senior Analyst for RAND Europe's Security, Defence and Infrastructure team.